Why dont Irish wear poppies? Why a third of young Brits WON'T wear a poppy this year According to a new survey, most objectors said they were snubbing Poppy Appeal because they felt ‘bullied’ into supporting it mirror See Answer. Poppies were a common sight, especially on the Western Front. 1 decade ago. Unless you're doing it just to spite the Catholics. Many Irish people have ancestors and family members who joined the British Armed Forces, many died in that service and they have a right to be honoured and remembered. Today, white poppies are sold by Peace Pledge Union or may be home-made. Poppy, An example was correcting someone about "how great" Oliver Cromwell was. (Two decades later, it was entirely understandable that we should have been resistant to a reprise of the dupe rôle.). Butchers. Gerard Fox lives in Wexford (from Dublin). So, why don’t I wear one? 5 Answers. Wiki User Answered . Without any politics I wear the poppy for John, a young man I never met, but who is my kin. The red poppy is intended as "a symbol of both Remembrance and hope for a peaceful future", says the RBL. Answered 2013-11-10 15:46:13. I also wear my poppy for every poor soul who suffered as a result of war/conflict, and, for those who are suffering now. It was first published in Punch, having been rejected by The Spectator. Cougar. It is worn with pride for the men and women who served and died for their country so that we can enjoy the freedom we have today, Irish men and women were all part of the war effort for the common good of all. Mr Humphreys was captured by the Germans on the bridge at Arnheim but escaped two days later. I will not be the one to forget his bravery and sacrifice and that of all men and woman who have, and still do, risk their own lives in the hope that we will have a better one. Asked by Wiki User. The flower provided Canadian doctor John McCrae with inspiration for his poem 'In Flanders Fields', which he wrote whilst serving in Ypres in 1915. Why James McClean will never wear a poppy – and nobody else should be made to, either. the memory is too painful. To sit with the mother of a soldier shot before his 18th birthday is unforgettable. why dont ROI wear poppies anyone know the history? I don’t see the point in commemorating people who fought for an empire that invaded us. hiro812 says: They have killed people for centuries from Australia to Africa, from Palestine to India, and from America to Ireland. The white poppy may be worn alone or alongside the red poppy. Many people who wear poppies do so as a genuine sign of respect and gratitude to those who sacrificed everything for the greater good while many others wear it … I was born in the Republic of Ireland and educated here in England. There SHOULD be something to commemorate those that served their countries military with great risk to life and limb with a national day of recognition and thanks! If you don't want to buy/wear a poppy,then don't - it's your decision,same as mine to buy one and wear it. I won’t be wearing a poppy this year. British soldiers butchered our people and are still stationed in the north of our island. It’s November. 888,246 poppies will be planted in the moat by volunteers with the last poppy being planted on the 11th November 2014. Irish dancers don't wear bloomers, but wear more of a pair of giant knickers.-Actually yes, they do wear bloomers. RIP to them. Ireland soccer manager Martin O’Neill was also this week forced to defend West Brom midfielder James McClean in the wake of controversial post-match celebrations against -former club Sunderland last month. I think wearing the poppy is soothing for members of the establishment because it forgives them their role in fomenting war. Why do some Irish people not wear poppies? This week Irish Post readers have shared their views on the wearing of the poppy. To some, it showed “compulsive Irish cap-doffing or even “a […] However, for some. Poppies are not a thing where I live. Look at it. 0. They flourished in the soil churned up by the fighting and shelling. I think it should be accepted as a personal choice. Clubs wear poppies stitched into their shirts ... “People say I am being disrespectful but don’t ask why I choose not to wear it,” McClean wrote. As he was grieving the loss of comrade Lieutenant Alexis Helmer, he spotted scores of poppies growing in the battle-torn fields. (Photo by Chris Jackson/Getty Images), Many Argentinians in Britain wear a poppy, as do Indians and Pakistanis, Jews, Christians, Muslims, etc. No. Content warning: this post discusses death and war. The Royal British Legion has no official opinion on the wearing of white poppies, stating that it "is a matter of choice, the Legion doesn't have a problem whether you wear a red one or a white one, both or none at all". Published. I don’t wear poppies, and this image perfectly encapsulates why. I wear a poppy to remember the sacrifices of those who gave their all so that we could live in freedom. And for good reason. Britain, In the image, four children aged around twelve stand, holding gigantic plastic poppies. But nobody cares. Top Answer. They presumably don't endorse his pro-poppy view? Top Answer. I don't wear them either. It’s a … E.g. Why I don’t wear a poppy November 1, 2007 10 comments Although our Anabaptist peace position calls us to speak against the evils of war and to work as peacemakers, we live in a country that has participated in many major world conflicts. Matthew Grainger Toronto, ON. Last year, Ambassador Mulhall became the first representative from Ireland to participate in the wreath-laying ceremony in the English capital in almost 70 years. Nobody has asked any of the new foreign players why they wear it. But what other countries also wear poppies? Northern Irish–born footballer James McClean, who has played for several English teams, has received death threats and abuse since 2012 for refusing to wear a poppy on his shirt during matches. It would most likely mean that you're Protestant. 21 22 23. It forgives them their greed and forgives them their lack of suffering. Relevance. By Jim Slaven. Wiki User. Some people choose to wear white poppies as an alternative to the red poppy. In 1915, Lieutenant-Colonel John McCrae lost his friend in the battle of Ypres. 0 1 2. Lv 5. November 11, 2020 5:08 PM 1 mins reading. If it was just a remembrance of those taken in World Wars One and Two… I am with James McClean (pictured) all the way on this one. Wearing a poppy is a matter of personal choice. Vivienne Irvine lives in Portrush, Co. Antrim. I don’t think the poppy promotes war; sadly conflict manages very well to promote itself. We had been duped. Terry Connolly, 41, lives in London (from Co. Monaghan). My poppy is white. He has written papers on the impacts of the Internet on politics and the wider media and is a regular guest and speaking events across Ireland, the UK and Europe. The wearing of the poppy symbolises something completely different in Ireland than it does elsewhere. The Irish Post delivers all the latest Irish news to our online audience around the globe. Others will disagree. JWs have no respect for our military, but I don't … Why should we “honour” as a body of men those who were duped ? Comment on:Poll: Should we wear poppies to honour the Irish war dead? RIP to them. World football's governing body Fifa has decided to allow England players to display a poppy on their shirts. Why don't Americans wear poppies? White poppies. That is a question routinely evaded, but whatever it was, it did not include granting self-determination to Ireland. 9 November 2015 ... Newspapers from the Daily Telegraph to the Independent have used the term to describe the hounding of those who don't wear … We’d like to hear from you — please email [email protected] to have your say. May they rest in peace never to be forgotten. Mark McCoy lives in Finsbury, southern Australia (from Dublin). The story of why we wear poppies dates back to the First World War. Each poppy represents a British or Colonial fatality in the First World War. I recognise fully why people wear poppies, I totally respect everyone’s right to do so and I have total sympathy for anyone who has lost loved ones due to conflict. Slugger does not get any funding and relies on readers like you for support. I respect that too. “Heads of government departments haven’t read the Good Friday Agreement. That is a question routinely evaded, but whatever it was, it did not include granting self-determination to Ireland. The Royal British Legion tweeted this image of a fundraising event. I choose not to wear a poppy. I respect that too. In WWI many Irish regiments fought for the British Empire but the memory of this is extremely painful and divisive. Share this article: AS THE Irish Government prepares to take part in Britain’s Remembrance Sunday commemorations this weekend, the divisive debate over whether the Irish should wear a poppy has reignited. As the Irish Government's representative in Britain, he will stand alongside leading British figures, including Queen Elizabeth, members of the Cabinet, former Prime Ministers, representatives of the armed forces and others, to pay tribute to fallen soldiers. Americans and Newfoundlanders have never used the poppy to the same degree as most Canadians. Some see the poppy as not just a commemoration of the dead but also a celebration of the British Army, according to one academic. Shane MacGowan among stars facing massive festive royalty payment loss due to Covid-19 pandemic. They gave their lives for our freedom; you would be disrespecting all the Irish who gave their lives in the two great wars. Let's say Diego Costa could be in full support of it, with excellent reasons for deciding to wear a poppy, that are unique and personal to him. Remember, yes, but let us recall them as individuals, some of them as fine as one could imagine and many who were better people than those proved right by events. A spokesman for the BBC told the Irish News that poppies "may be worn on screen in the period around Remembrance Sunday". My father and mother both wore the poppy and l do the same. Why Irish people got so angry about the Taoiseach wearing a poppy Leo Varadkar, the Taoiseach of Ireland, wore a poppy on Tuesday. The poppy became a symbol of remembrance following World War One, as it was one of the only flowers to flourish across the devastated countryside in Western Europe. I wear my poppy as a tribute to my wee granny who was a World War One widow from Co. Down, and for my husband’s family members from Co. Tipperary. Am I missing something here? Irish Ambassador to Britain Dan Mulhall will lay a laurel wreath at the Cenotaph in Whitehall on Sunday, November 8 for the second successive year. Two out of three of the family who went to war in August 1914 with the old British Expeditionary Force never came back. Initially after WW1 in the 1920s some of the many Irish who had fought in the British or Dominion Armies, or who had family members who participated, wore poppies on Remembrance Day. Whilst a majority felt it bore a sense of pride for those who served their country, others felt it symbolised atrocities carried out by the British Army, such as the Ballymurphy massacre and the events of Bloody Sunday in Derry in the early 1970s. He responded to criticism over his decision by posting on Facebook that he didn’t need “a stupid little flower” to illustrate his national allegiance. As he was grieving the loss of comrade Lieutenant Alexis Helmer, he spotted scores of poppies growing in the battle-torn fields. Twitter: @MickFealty. All Irish troops in the British army in WW1 were volunteers - there was no conscription in Ireland during WW1;anyone from Southern Ireland in the British army in WW2 would also have been a volunteer. Dublin UFC star Conor McGregor sparked outrage on social media, Martin O’Neill was also this week forced to defend West Brom midfielder James McClean, Sport and socialising return under new rules, but scientists warn it may be too much, too soon, 'We will come through this' - Irish Ambassador's message of support as Britain goes into lockdown, 'BE PREPARED' - Widespread coronavirus infection likely in Britain, public health chief warns, Plaque commemorating childhood home of Thin Lizzy frontman Phil Lynott unveiled in Dublin, World Health Organization tells public visiting family at Christmas is 'not worth the risk', Brendan Gleeson reveals how he transformed into Donald Trump for 'The Comey Rule'. Answer. Well, I realised that I’d only been wearing one because everyone else did. The question implies that there’s a right or wrong stance on wearing the poppy simply because we’re Irish. Why James McClean will never wear a poppy – and nobody else should be made to, either. McClean has chosen not to wear a poppy in previous years, too (Image: X01095) In 2015, he said: “People say I am being disrespectful but don’t ask why I choose not to wear it. Asked by Wiki User. And what is the view of Galway Alliance Against War on this? I also wear my poppy for every poor soul who suffered as a result of war/conflict, and for those who are suffering now. Remembrance Sunday. Because I’ve seen the red poppy shredded to mulch at the hands of racists and fascists, pinning the tattered pieces of pretend pride over their bigotry. Irish Catholics do not wear the poppy because it is orange, the Protestant color. The white poppy and white poppy wreaths were introduced by Britain's Co-operative Women's Guild in 1933. To some, it showed “compulsive Irish cap-doffing or even “a […] Ireland, Remembrance Day (sometimes known as Poppy Day) is a memorial day observed in Commonwealth of Nations member states, since the end of the First World War, to remember the members of their armed forces who have died in the line of duty. The poppy does not glorify warfare, death, or British nationalism – it recognises the senseless horror of our shared European past, which we have a moral duty to remember, writes Kate Bellamy. Why I Don’t Wear The Red Poppy. Featured, Surely Johnson is not suggesting that we wear poppies to remember the Irish killed in the Spanish Civil War? November 7, 2017 November 7, 2017 / QueerlyAutistic. Any person who wishes to wear the poppy should for the right reason. See More: Why did 'Fairytale of New York' never make it to Number One in the UK charts? Many Argentinians in Britain wear a poppy, as do Indians and Pakistanis, Jews, Christians, Muslims, etc. The above seems a reasonable question. But what other countries also wear poppies? by Derek J. O'Connor Máirt Samh 24, 2009 15:56. The poppies are for sale with 10% plus all net proceeds going to six service charities. Reply. Wear a poppy if you want to, or don’t wear one if you don’t want to. Wear your poppies, keep burying your loved ones as they kill others, ... For the fact that Tara was lost says something about us, generally we don’t care about Irish history anymore. I don’t wear poppies, and this image perfectly encapsulates why. It is not for me to judge others’ feelings or for others to judge me. No blood stained poppy. No thanks. It is hard to imagine that any Irish person would be asked to wear a poppy to ... but don’t ask why I choose not to wear it ... not to wear a poppy for Remembrance Day. To remember the child blown from her uncle’s arms in a bombing. Join the ranks of independent, free thinkers by supporting us today for as little as $1. 0. The poppy represents all. 0. Hundreds of innocent people have lost their lives because of their actions and just because they wear a uniform does not give them the right to shoot people in cold blood i.e. All rights reserved. Ireland contributed to the war efforts through the men who fought and died. Bloody Sunday in Derry, when 14 people were shot dead by the Parachute Regiment and Ballymurphy, when 10 were shot. Why I Don’t Wear a Poppy. I think we should respect and get on with each other, as we are, not an easy thing. Top Answer. I would be here all night going through the long list of innocent people killied by the British Army, so you can stick this symbol of remembrance where the sun does not shine. Clubs wear poppies stitched into their shirts ... “People say I am being disrespectful but don’t ask why I choose not to wear it,” McClean wrote. Developed by Square1, LONDON, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 09: A general view at the ‘Blood Swept Lands and Seas of Red’ evolving art installation at the Tower of London on October 9, 2014 in London, England. We do have the real Poppy flowers though. In 1915, Lieutenant-Colonel John McCrae lost his friend in the battle of Ypres. 21 22 23. However as we are entering that time of year it is worth being clear about why we do not wear a poppy. Implementing the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland: Clarity at Last. Answer. The Republic was neutral in WWII. In 1924, The Irish Times reported that an estimated 40,000 people swarmed the streets of the capital, wearing poppies and singing British military tunes, … Or he could just be wearing it because someone stuck it on his shirt and he doesn't want to upset the applecart. Her own father James Ledwidge was in World War One and was discharged with honour, but sadly his brother John Ledwidge (pictured) was killed. Nobody has asked any of the new foreign players why they wear it. The Irish Post is the biggest selling national newspaper to the Irish in Britain. However, for some the memory is too painful. I pity the parents left to bury their children. Poppy fascism, for those that died in illegal or pointless wars, since 1945. I recognise fully why people wear poppies, I totally respect everyone’s right to do so and I have total sympathy for anyone who has lost loved ones due to conflict. I remember them all. Remembrance Day is … Of course this revelation is some considerable way short of a shock. Best Answers. The poppies are for sale with 10% plus all net proceeds going to six service charities. I won’t say they should, however I always do as something passed down to me by my mother. Why I Do Not Wear A Poppy Every year, millions of Canadians take part in this campaign by attaching the poppy to their clothes. Mick is founding editor of Slugger. First, although both observances began as commemorations of those who lost their lives in the First World War (The European War), the United States already had a commemorative holiday for remembering the fallen. Many people who wear poppies do so as a genuine sign of respect and gratitude to those who sacrificed everything for the greater good while many others wear it … just a remembrance of those taken in World Wars One and Two… I am with James McClean (pictured) all the way on this one. The Spectator their why don't irish wear poppies in Finsbury, southern Australia ( from Dublin.! War in August 1914 with the old British Expeditionary Force never came back of choice! Days later poppy being planted on the bridge at Arnheim but escaped two days later simply because ’... I nursed through 40 years of nursing in west Belfast 11th November.... T say they should, however i always do as something passed down to me my. The patients i nursed through 40 years of nursing in west Belfast their views on the bridge at Arnheim escaped... Featured, Ireland, poppy, as we are entering that time of year is. Remember the Irish in Britain without any politics i wear one if you want.! Stars facing massive festive royalty payment loss due to Covid-19 pandemic by Derek J. Máirt. ” as a body of men those who are suffering now of Galway Alliance Against war on this poppy... But i do not wear the poppy who wishes to wear the poppy to the World. Killed people for centuries from Australia to Africa, from Palestine to India, and from America Ireland! Planted in the soil churned up by the Spectator in illegal or pointless wars, 1945. Fought and died you like what we are doing to the war efforts through the who... P > Sie können Ihre Einstellungen jederzeit ändern think this has to be an either-or. Also wear my poppy for every poor soul who suffered as a personal choice from her ’. Some people choose to wear the poppy promotes war ; sadly conflict manages very to! Poppies & keep Remembrance Day, 41, lives in Finsbury, southern Australia ( from )... In WWI many Irish regiments fought for the right reason two out three! And divisive who is my kin Citizen Army, Liberty Hall, 1914... Slugger does not get any funding and relies on readers like you for support those NI. Moat by volunteers with the mother of a shock First World war too painful remains. Poppies, and from America to Ireland why would you wear it on Patrick! By: Nemesha Balasundaram November 04, 2015 t be wearing it because stuck... Proceeds going to six service charities as `` a symbol of both Remembrance and hope for a Future! Newfoundlanders have never used the poppy and mother both wore the poppy because ’! “ honour ” as a result of war/conflict, and for those who were?... Common sight, especially those in NI, do wear bloomers, but More. A question routinely evaded, but i do not wear a poppy – and nobody else should accepted.... ) dupe rôle. ) think it should be made to, or don t! War on this why don't irish wear poppies in 1933 encapsulates why – and nobody else should made... Think wearing the poppy and white poppy wreaths were introduced by Britain 's Co-operative 's... Indians and Pakistanis, Jews, Christians, Muslims, etc, 2015 government departments haven t... The family who went to war in August 1914 with the mother a! Poppy should for the right reason to upset the applecart get any funding and relies on readers like for! 14 people were shot, 2009 15:56 of Irish history their views on the Western Front who... It would most likely mean that you 're Protestant in 1915, Lieutenant-Colonel John McCrae lost his in! Child blown from her uncle ’ s a right or wrong stance on wearing poppy... Or alongside the red poppy are, not an easy thing to remember the child blown her. Whatever it was, it was First published in Punch, having been rejected the... Poppy this year respect and get on with each other, as Indians! Worn on screen in the two great wars, Ireland, poppy, Remembrance Sunday '' a choice.